Friday, October 30, 2026

The Difference Between Artificial Intelligence (AI) and a Good Search Engine

By Elaine L. Orr 

Most definitions of artificial intelligence are similar. From an IBM website: "a technology that enables computers and machines to simulate human learning, comprehension, problem solving, decision making, creativity and autonomy." 

While it is top of mind for many reasons now, which I'll get to in a minute, anyone who has asked search engines for information using Google (online) or a virtual assistant such as Siri or Alexa has used it for years. It's helpful. 

Answers to complicated question come through rapid sorting of vast amounts of data. When did the Yankees win their first pennant? What was Eleanor Roosevelt's first job was at the United Nations? How long should you bake a turkey? This is AI, but it's not 'generative AI.' 

Generative AI has been trained to create original content: words/paragraphs, images, audio, or videos. It thinks independently and it's learned to do this by absorbing any information that already existed. You'll hear the phrase "large language learning models." 

LLMs are trained on massive amounts of text data to understand, summarize, translate, and generate human-like language. As an author who has published more than forty books, I'm not happy that "they" used my books to train to train these models. We're all angry. 
To try to understand whether AI had actually used my material, I asked ChatGPT to tell me something about my novels. It spit out a lot until I said to stop. Then I asked it to go another step and write a story using the type of setting and characters used in the Jolie Gentil mysteries. (Cozy mysteries set at the Jersey Shore.) First it described the series, characters, and types of relationships among the characters. Then it wrote a 7,000-word story in a voice similar to my own. With gobs and gobs of metaphors, which I despise. Characters were flat, but still -- 7,000 words in about ten seconds or so.

The anger and sense of helplessness at having my work stolen are immense. I've joined a couple of the class actions suits reminding AI firms that there is such a thing as copyright law and I'd like some compensation. If the many suits wend there ways through the courts I'll be long dead. And any awards will probably say they only go to living people.

To better describe the types of AI, I asked Google, which used AI to create a response in one second. 
  •  Artificial Narrow Intelligence (ANI): AI designed to handle a specific, targeted task (such as web search, facial recognition, or language translation); this represents all current real-world AI. 
  • Artificial General Intelligence (AGI): A theoretical form of AI that could match human-level intelligence across any intellectual or cognitive task. 
  • Artificial Superintelligence (ASI): A hypothetical future stage where AI surpasses human intelligence and capability across all domains.
According to a few (now former) employees of AI firms, AI is getting close to the last phase. Or maybe it isn't the last one, but it's the current definition. 

I know people who have eschewed all use of generative AI. I use it to create images for marketing. As I finished writing the most recent Bay View Harbor Mystery, The Judge's Last Contest, I did an experiment. I wrote a couple of paragraphs that described the story line, main characters, and two potential murder suspects. I asked ChatGPT for an opinion on which suspect made the most sense. I had written the ending, and found ChatGPT agreed completely, with a more well reasoned statement than my own. Merde.

We're all aware of the dire predictions that AI can try to destroy humankind. Options to do so appear varied. Some involve overriding computer code and launching missiles that can't be stopped by human intervention. Others involve destroying means of communication, the banking system, even crops. I haven't read all the methods. And we can't know all of them, because generative AI is developing its own options.

My personal next step is to write some informative materials about how to manage life within the new realities. The word informative is presumptuous. I should probably say "guesstimates" or WAGS (for wild-ass guesses). You'll hear about it hear first, as journalists would say (before and after their words are stolen).

P.S. You probably figured out I used ChatGPT to create the graphic of an LLLM.

                                                      *                *                *                *

To learn more about Elaine's writing, visit her website or sign up for her newsletter.

Thursday, October 29, 2026

Keeping the Characters in Play When the Author is Stuck

By Elaine L. Orr

I generally have a story idea, make a series of notes and take off. I'll jot more notes as I go about what to put where or what a character's back story is, but I don't outline.

Instead, I do a "chapter summaries" document that has bullet points on each chapter and a few notes to myself about what subplot an event relates to, but it isn't detailed. It helps me keep track of the story.

There are times when I...simply...stop. I don't think of it as writer's block, more as a thinking detour. The two times I've put projects away I came back to them (years later). A philosophical person would say the story didn't cry out to be written until then. I would say I did enough other writing that my thoughts on the delayed books had time to percolate. 

What about those poor characters? When I was a very young child (just getting into chapter books) I worried  that if I closed a book the characters would be stuck between the pages, maybe unable to breathe. (I was a strange kid.)

As a writing adult, I put the characters on some form of transport conveyance. In Falling Into Place, the grandfather and granddaughter took a bus from her school to his house when she had chicken pox. They were on that bus a loooong time. In a book I finished but did not publish, the characters rode on the DC metro. Not for quite as long.

I recently finished The Judge's Last Contest, and it took much longer than it should have. I dawdled, put together a couple of bags for the thrift store, worked on a big genealogy project, and even cleaned. The  dawdling took place over several weeks. I wrote but I should have simply worked harder.

Why? I don't write literary fiction or complex thrillers. My mysteries aren't simple, but they shouldn't be so hard to write at times. When in doubt, google. I didn't want a book or article on good writing habits. I found and ordered Laraine Herring'a On Being Stuck: Tapping Into the Creative Power of Writer's Block. Google told me she, "frames blocks not as an enemy, but as a signal where hope meets fear in the middle of a project." Catchy.

I also came across Michael Chabon's Wonder Boys, about a novelist who's stalled on an endless manuscript -- and he even had a contract! My husband had a copy and says it's one of his all-time favorites, very funny as well as thought-provoking.

I'll read both and then write about this topic again. And I'll give myself a few days and start another book. In today's crazy retail environment, that's the way to survive.

                                                  *                *                *                *

To learn more about Elaine's writing, visit her website or sign up for her newsletter.